4 East State Street demolition appeal (Alexander Blacksmith Shop)
Summary
The Shodeen Family Foundation appealed the HPC's 7-0 denial of a demolition permit for the landmarked 19th-century stone structure. The council couldn't muster the seven votes needed to reverse, so the walls stay up — and the 8-year redevelopment stalemate at the former Millrace Inn site continues.
At a glance
- Total mentions
- 3
- Last 30 days
- 1
Last discussed Jan 12, 2026.
Impact analysis
The site's redevelopment — and any tax base gain — remains stalled while the deteriorating structure stands.
Preservation supporters and residents who opposed demolition keep the landmark standing.
The property owner remains unable to redevelop the site, and residents wanting change on the corner stay waiting.
Mentions & discussions (3)
🌱 Patch AM: Will Geneva’s riverfront become condos or a historic park hub?
Hi there, Geneva! We've got your morning read ready! Read on to stay connected. ☀️ In today's newsletter:Will Geneva's riverfront become condos or a historic park hub?See how much a Le Baron Court home just sold...
City Council - Jan 12, 2026
The Shodeen Family Foundation appealed the HPC's 7-0 denial of a demolition permit for the landmarked 19th-century stone structure. The council couldn't muster the seven votes needed to reverse, so the walls stay up — and the 8-year redevelopment stalemate at the former Millrace Inn site continues.
City Council - Jan 5, 2026
A resident invited the public to a Thursday event unveiling a researched scale model of the 1840s Blacksmith Shop on Mill Race property, ahead of next week's council decision on a demolition permit, and promised a preservation vision with historical, commercial, and tourism value.
Related development
4 East State Street Historic Landmark Demolition Appeal
The historic stone walls stay standing on a prominent downtown corner, and any redevelopment of the former Millrace Inn site remains frozen until the impasse is resolved.
Alexander Brothers Blacksmith Shop demolition permit
The council's demolition permit decision next week will determine the future of the historic Mill Race structure.
We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda and when it's voted on, at most once a day.
The weekly brief for Geneva
What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.
Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.