Civic Issues
Topics getting the most attention in Highland Park public meetings, ranked by how frequently they are discussed.
26 issues in zoning
Porsche Exchange expansion into former CVS on Skokie Valley Road
The vacant former CVS would become a locked display building for high-end collector Porsches, with sales and walk-ins kept at the main dealership. The commission attached four conditions and neighbors won commitments on repairs, deliveries, and traffic, though they failed to get a westbound-turn restriction at the Park Avenue West intersection.
Towing and Impound Lot Operation at 1325 Park Avenue West
GF Towing and Recovery sought a special use permit to operate a towing and impound lot on a portion of the property at 1325 Park Avenue West. Nearby residents expressed concerns over noise, lights, traffic, and vehicle storage capacity.
451 Broadview Avenue FAR variance
A Ravinia family on one of Highland Park's smallest lots needed approval to enclose a water-damaged rooftop deck as living space, exceeding the allowed floor-area ratio by 108 square feet. The board weighed three written neighbor objections against the unchanged footprint and voted unanimously yes.
Historic Preservation Incentives and Demolition Tax
City Council is working out how to offer incentives for historic preservation, following an April 27 Committee of the Whole meeting. A commissioner who watched noted there was 'a lot of confusion' but credited the Council for taking it on.
Inadequate cellular coverage in Ravinia
Cell phone service in the Ravinia area is reportedly spotty — even ambulance crews lose hospital contact while driving up Green Bay Road. This zoning change opens the door for providers to install small rooftop antennas to fill the gaps.
Personal training facility at 581 Roger Williams Avenue
A vacant office building gets a new lease on life as a one-on-one personal training studio, with parking and traffic checked out fine. The building stays the same on the outside, so neighbors shouldn't notice much change.
Data center zoning text amendment
The commission wants to ban data centers as a land use before anyone proposes one, citing noise, air pollution, and huge water and electricity demands that don't fit a residential community. The City Council has the final say.
1569 Forest Avenue fence height variation and neighbor objection
A 6-foot fence to screen a neighbor's new pool house stirred pushback from Eva Soutsos, who argued it could set a precedent and questioned whether the parcels were truly adjacent. The board noted fence standards are more lenient, apologized for wrong standards posted online, and approved it unanimously.
85 Hemlock Lane shed setback variation
A homeowner wants to replace an old shed 3 feet from the side property line where 12 feet is required. Flooding and mature oak trees leave no other spot on the lot, and the board agreed the standards were met.
Incorrect variation standards posted on city website
A resident prepared her entire case using the wrong (stricter) standards listed on the city's website for the fence case. The chair apologized and the board debated whether that unfairness should change the outcome.
Sport court at Keshet group home
A group home for adults with disabilities needed a variance to build a small basketball court in its rear yard, exceeding coverage limits. The board weighed strict zoning standards against the home's mission of safe, independent living.
Garage addition setback encroachment at 421 Briarwood Place
A homeowner needed permission to rebuild a failing 100-year-old garage slightly into side and rear setbacks. Neighbors supported it and the board approved unanimously.
Substitute materials for historic properties
The commission is exploring when modern replacement materials (like synthetic siding) are acceptable on historic homes. A resident warned that testing and traceability of these products can be problematic.
Front-yard setback variation at 406 Woodland Road
A 1937 home already sits closer to the street than today's rules allow, and the owners want to add a second-floor addition that follows the same line. The board found the hardship is the site context and approved the relief with eight neighbor letters of support.
Fence in the Deere Park Drive subdivision building line
A corner-lot owner wanted a 4-foot aluminum fence along his lot's tree line, but a subdivision building line dating to the 1930s treats fences as structures and would have forced the fence through the middle of his side yard. The board agreed the hardship was real and approved the encroachment.
Withdrawn applications and empty summer docket
Two variance applications (879 Burton Ave and 353 N. Deere Park Dr. E) were withdrawn, leaving the board with no pending cases. Upcoming May meetings and the June 4 continuance are expected to be cancelled.
Peers No-Smoking House Rule
Smoking and vaping are now banned throughout the Peers building, a change in the works since at least April when Sunset Woods made a similar move.
Excess garage door openings on Park Avenue West
A new home on a busy street wants 54 feet of garage door openings where 36 is allowed — six 9-foot doors tucked in courtyards and screened by landscaping. The board found the multi-generational household's needs justified the relief.
Security fence height variation on Waverly Road
The lakefront estate at 1425 Waverly Road can build a 6-foot fence and gate in the front yard — 2 feet over the limit — after testimony that security consultants advised the height because of threats against the owner. The design is set back 30 feet and screened by hedges.
Front-yard variance for 3504 Dato Avenue addition
A 1955 home already sits too close to Dato Avenue, so adding a garage and laundry room needs relief from the 40-foot front-yard rule. The board agreed keeping the existing footprint preserves the home's character.
Landmark designation of 670 De Tamble Avenue (Arthur Vetter House)
The 1928 Tudor-style Arthur Vetter House, a past preservation award winner, is one step from local landmark protection, which restricts exterior changes and demolition.
Zoning Board of Appeals report
Councilmember Center reported the ZBA has handled 22 variation applications across 14 meetings this year, with no heritage tree removal cases.
Local Landmark Designation of 818 Hill Street
A 1927 Tudor-style summer house tied to Edith Rockefeller McCormick, with what may be Highland Park's oldest hand-hewn logs, could become an official landmark. The owners support it and the commission unanimously moved it forward — a win for preservation, though it means future exterior changes would face review.
Unpermitted garage addition at 879 Burton Avenue
A family of contractors built a garage addition without a permit in 2025 and now needs variances to keep it — including 89% rear-yard coverage where 50% is allowed. The board said the ask is too big and gave them until May 7 to come back smaller.
Pool side-yard variance at 2021 Old Briar Road
A homeowner wants to build a pool, buried pool equipment, and a gazebo that push 6.5 to 8.5 feet into required side-yard setbacks on a corner lot. Neighbors raised flooding, drainage, noise, and visual-privacy concerns, and the board pushed the decision to a later meeting so the applicant can refine the plan.
New home and tree preservation at 1139 Ridgewood Road
A new single-family home needs a 15.7-foot encroachment into the established building setback so heritage and key trees in the rear can be saved. Neighbors supported it as long as it stays single-family.