1657 Shermer Road redevelopment and downtown vitality
Summary
The village agreed to sell the old Grainger site's Lot 2 for $10.5 million to a developer proposing a five-story, 272-unit luxury apartment building with 40 affordable units and ground-floor retail. Trustees were enthusiastic, calling it a long-awaited downtown catalyst.
At a glance
- Total mentions
- 5
- Last 30 days
- 2
Discussed at 2 meetings in the last 60 days; most recently Oct 21, 2026.
Impact analysis
$10.5 million in sale proceeds to the village, with closing tied to building permit issuance.
Renters seeking downtown living, downtown businesses wanting more customers, and the village's general fund.
No direct harm identified, though neighbors may raise traffic concerns as the application proceeds.
Mentions & discussions (5)
Plan Commission (Special) - Oct 21, 2026
Multiple commissioners said 11,000 square feet of retail is a non-starter for the heart of downtown, citing the village's plans calling for commercial-first redevelopment and the risk of dead storefronts. Pulte counters that market demand — including three vacant spaces across the street — limits how much retail the site can support.
Plan Commission (Special) - Oct 20, 2026
Speaker after speaker objected to six-story, 68-foot buildings, saying they'd wall off downtown, loom over the church and memorial garden, and change Northbrook's character forever. The base zoning allows four stories.
Village Board of Trustees (Agenda Packet Amended) - May 26, 2026
The village agreed to sell the old Grainger site's Lot 2 for $10.5 million to a developer proposing a five-story, 272-unit luxury apartment building with 40 affordable units and ground-floor retail. Trustees were enthusiastic, calling it a long-awaited downtown catalyst.
Plan Commission - May 19, 2026
Staff data shows Northbrook's downtown has roughly half the residential density of neighbors like Highland Park — about 2,800 units within a mile of the train station. The argument: without more rooftops, the restaurants and shops residents keep asking for won't come. Commissioners debated whether to add 500-600 downtown units, whether seniors need smaller homes rather than apartments, and the new state 'people over parking' law removing parking mandates near Metra.
Village Board of Trustees - May 12, 2026
The village is moving to sell its 1657 Shermer Road parcel to The Habitat Company for roughly 300-318 apartments plus commercial space, aiming to add downtown foot traffic and housing diversity. Trustees cited the downtown's ~2,800 nearby housing units versus 5,000-6,800 in neighboring communities. The sale contract and any zoning approvals still face future public votes.
Related development
Pulte Planned Unit Development at 1901-1975 Cherry Lane (Meadow Plaza) - PCD-26-05
If built, downtown loses roughly 90,000 sq ft of retail and gains 150 condos, a small public square, and a village-owned incubator program — plus traffic, stormwater, and parking questions for neighbors and the church.
Meadow Plaza Mixed-Use Development
The outcome shapes whether downtown's existing local businesses (including services relied on by residents with disabilities) are replaced by up to six-story residential buildings; concerns raised include traffic, schools, flooding, environmental conditions, and parking.
1657 Shermer Road Redevelopment (former Granger property)
The largest of the downtown proposals; residents worry about school crowding, traffic, and loss of the site to dense residential use.
Village of Northbrook Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan Amendments
Mostly housekeeping for the zoning code, but homeowners near industrial sites and on through lots regain taller-fence rights, and EV charging and sport courts get clear treatment.
We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda and when it's voted on, at most once a day.
The weekly brief for Northbrook
What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.
Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.